Editor-in-Chief’s Message

Ijtihad Journal: From Within the Islamic Intellectual Tradition and at the Heart of the European Context

In the contemporary world, knowledge is no longer merely an accumulated body of information and ideas. It has become one of the principal determinants of civilizational presence and active participation in shaping intellectual, cultural, and social transformations. Amid the rapid changes taking place in contemporary societies, there is an increasing need to develop academic projects capable of generating knowledge, exercising independent intellectual reasoning, renewing the tools of thought, and contributing to international scholarly debates from intellectually independent and open perspectives.

Within this context, Ijtihad Journal for Islamic and Arabic Studies, published by the Ijtihad Center for Studies and Training in Belgium, positions itself as an academic project seeking to contribute to the development of Islamic and Arabic studies and to strengthen their presence in university and research environments, particularly in Europe and the West. The journal was not established merely out of a desire to add another academic periodical to the publishing landscape. Rather, it emerged from an awareness of the epistemological and methodological needs arising from the transformations in Muslim presence within European and Western societies, as well as from an aspiration to create a scholarly space in which Islam, the Arabic language, and their related issues can be studied from multiple research perspectives, within a framework of academic rigour, intellectual openness, and responsible criticism.

The distinctive character of the Ijtihad project stems from its endeavour to bring together two complementary intellectual standpoints: approaching the study of Islam and its related issues from within the Islamic intellectual tradition, and examining Muslim presence and its transformations in Europe and the West from within the European context itself. The journal therefore does not approach Islam exclusively as an object of study from an external perspective, nor does it regard Muslims in Europe as an imported phenomenon or as a subject detached from the context in which they live. Instead, it seeks to develop an academic approach grounded in direct engagement with both Islamic intellectual reference frameworks and European realities.

From the Transformations of Muslim Presence to the Need for Knowledge Production

Over recent decades, Muslim presence in Europe and the West has undergone profound transformations. It is no longer confined to contexts of migration and settlement but has become part of the social, cultural, and institutional fabric of these societies. Successive generations of Muslims have contributed to education, academic research, civil society, politics, media, and the economy. Consequently, issues relating to Islam and Muslims have become increasingly prominent in media, political, and academic debates, creating a need for more developed tools of understanding, analysis, and interpretation.

These transformations have been accompanied by a notable expansion of Arabic and Islamic studies within European and Western universities and research centres, through academic programmes, conferences, publications, and specialised scholarly journals. These efforts have contributed to the development of important fields of knowledge and to a body of research that cannot be overlooked or dispensed with.

Nevertheless, the expansion of these fields does not eliminate the need to broaden the perspectives from which they are approached and to strengthen the plurality of intellectual reference frameworks and methodologies involved in their study. Islamic intellectual traditions, with their classical sources and contemporary interpretations, deserve an active scholarly presence in the study of Islam and its related issues, alongside historical, linguistic, sociological, philosophical, anthropological, and other approaches. Knowledge develops through dialogue, criticism, and the plurality of perspectives, rather than through reliance on a single standpoint or confinement within a limited intellectual framework.

From this perspective, Ijtihad maintains that the development of Islamic studies in Europe cannot be achieved simply by expanding their subject areas or increasing the number of institutions engaged in them. It also requires broadening the intellectual standpoints from which knowledge is approached and produced. Just as Western scholars are entitled to study Islam from the standpoint of their own intellectual backgrounds and epistemological frameworks, scholars whose intellectual formation is rooted in the Islamic tradition are equally entitled to contribute to the study of their religion, heritage, and community-related issues from within that tradition, in accordance with the standards of rigorous academic research. A researcher's Islamic background should not constitute an obstacle to the recognition of their scholarly work; equally, their religious or intellectual background should never serve as a substitute for methodological rigour, critical inquiry, and evidence-based argumentation.

An Intellectual Vision Based on the Internal Approach and Critical Dialogue

Ijtihad Journal proceeds from a fundamental conviction: the study of Islam in the European and Western context requires critical intellectual dialogue between internal approaches grounded in Islamic intellectual reference frameworks and external approaches developed within modern academic research, particularly Orientalist and Islamological studies. This dialogue does not entail placing these approaches in predetermined opposition or automatically privileging one over the other. Rather, it recognises that they emerge from different premises, questions, and methodological tools, and seeks to examine their respective possibilities and limitations and to draw upon them in ways that serve the research question.

The journal attaches particular importance to the internal approach to Islam. This approach entails studying Islam on the basis of its own sources and intellectual reference frameworks, engaging with its disciplines and exegetical, legal, intellectual, and spiritual traditions, and understanding its questions within their historical and civilizational contexts. This does not, however, mean suspending scholarly criticism or treating the Islamic heritage as a closed domain beyond scrutiny and reassessment. Such an approach is particularly significant in the European context, where Orientalist and Islamological studies constitute well-established academic traditions in a number of universities and research centres, while there remains a need to expand the presence of scholarship that approaches Islam from within its own intellectual tradition and enables both Muslim and non-Muslim researchers to engage with Islam as a religious, intellectual, and civilizational system with its own sources, concepts, and disciplines.

The distinctive character of Ijtihad Journal extends beyond this intellectual dimension to its geographical and epistemological position in Europe. The journal approaches Islam and Muslims in Europe and the West from within the European context itself, paying particular attention to the social, institutional, educational, cultural, and religious experiences that shape Muslim presence in these societies. Accordingly, it does not treat European Islam as a distant subject to be studied from outside its context, nor merely as an extension of migration-related topics examined from the perspective of the Arab and Muslim worlds. Rather, it approaches Islam and Muslim communities as part of contemporary European reality, with their own histories, transformations, questions, institutions, and actors.

The journal's project thus brings together two complementary approaches: an internal approach to Islam in terms of its intellectual and epistemological foundations, and a European approach in terms of the geographical and contextual setting in which issues relating to Islam and Muslims are examined. This convergence is one of the defining features of Ijtihad Journal and gives it a distinctive position within the specialised academic landscape of Islamic and Arabic studies in Europe.

On this basis, the journal does not adopt an exclusionary stance towards Orientalist, Islamological, or other Western academic traditions. Nor does it regard the Islamic heritage as a closed domain immune to criticism or reassessment. Instead, it seeks to develop a balanced scholarly approach that engages with the intellectual heritage, draws upon modern methodologies, and subjects different perspectives and findings to critical examination, dialogue, and evidence-based argumentation.

This orientation does not involve an eclectic or uncritical combination of methodologies, nor does it entail employing ready-made research tools without awareness of their theoretical foundations. Rather, it recognises that each research question has its own requirements and that methodological choices should be guided by the nature of the subject, the objectives of the study, and the available evidence. Awareness of the epistemological and methodological foundations of research is therefore an essential condition for producing rigorous and independent knowledge.

From a Culture of Publishing to Knowledge Production

At Ijtihad Journal, we believe that academic publishing is not an end in itself, but a means of contributing to the advancement of knowledge and the development of scholarly debate. The growing emphasis on academic publishing and its professional and institutional requirements should not obscure the fundamental purpose of research: asking meaningful questions, developing theoretical perspectives, testing hypotheses, analysing data, and offering original scholarly contributions.

The journal therefore seeks to encourage research that demonstrates a clear intellectual vision, is grounded in well-defined research questions, employs appropriate and justified methodologies, and moves beyond description and compilation towards analysis, criticism, and the construction of well-supported arguments. It also attaches particular importance to scholarly originality, analytical depth, accurate referencing, substantive engagement with previous research, and the extent to which a study contributes to the development of its respective field.

The journal does not assess the value of research solely on the basis of the number of references it contains, the topicality of its subject, or the quality of its language. The essence of academic work lies in its capacity to generate deeper understanding, offer a new interpretation, reassess an established perspective, or open up a research avenue that has not received sufficient attention. Accordingly, the quality of the research question, methodology, argumentation, and scholarly contribution constitutes a fundamental pillar of the journal's editorial and peer-review approach.

Areas of Interest and Academic Openness

The journal covers a broad range of fields within Islamic and Arabic studies, including Qur'anic and Hadith studies, the sciences of the Qur'an and Hadith, Islamic jurisprudence and thought, the Arabic language and literature, historical and civilizational studies, Orientalism and Islamology, comparative religious studies, interreligious dialogue, religious and cultural pluralism, Islam in Europe and the West, and issues concerning Muslim communities in contemporary societies.

The journal also encourages interdisciplinary research that facilitates interaction between different academic disciplines, provided that it is grounded in clear scholarly foundations and respects the methodological requirements of each field. It remains open to researchers from diverse academic, geographical, and linguistic backgrounds and seeks to strengthen communication between universities and research centres in the Arab world, Europe, and other international contexts.

The journal regards intellectual plurality as a condition for the vitality of academic research. It therefore does not require authors to adopt predetermined conclusions or intellectual positions, nor does it regard disagreement with the views of the editorial board as grounds for rejecting a submission. The primary criteria are the quality of the research, the soundness of its argumentation, the clarity of its methodology, and its adherence to academic integrity and publication ethics.

Academic Development and Renewed Ambition

During the three years following its establishment, Ijtihad has moved from its initial founding stage and the development of its conceptual framework towards consolidating its academic experience and expanding its presence. It has worked to ensure the regular publication of its issues, develop its editorial and peer-review structures, expand its network of editors, advisers, and reviewers, strengthen its linguistic presence through publication in Arabic and English, and broaden its engagement with researchers and academic institutions.

Articles published in the journal have also begun to gain visibility on academic and research platforms, and some have received scholarly citations. These developments represent preliminary indications that the journal's academic output is entering wider circuits of scholarly exchange. They reflect the progress of a growing academic initiative and provide further motivation to continue improving editorial and scholarly quality and strengthening the journal's international presence.

Nevertheless, we recognise that establishing an academic journal with a well-grounded reputation is a long-term undertaking. It requires sustained institutional commitment, rigorous peer-review standards, independence in editorial decision-making, and a continuous effort to attract original research and scholars with serious academic projects. It also requires regular reflection and evaluation, learning from challenges, and improving working procedures in accordance with international academic standards without compromising the journal's intellectual identity.

Towards a Productive and Open Scholarly Space

Ijtihad Journal aspires to become an academic platform that contributes to the production of rigorous and evolving knowledge, strengthens dialogue between different intellectual reference frameworks and research traditions, and participates actively in the study of Islam, the Arabic language, and issues concerning Muslim communities in the contemporary world. It seeks to develop a distinctive scholarly identity based neither on intellectual isolation nor on claims to possess absolute truth, but on independent thinking, in-depth research, critical openness, and respect for scholarly disagreement.

The journal's project is rooted in the conviction that knowledge entails responsibility and that academic research is not merely a response to the requirements of publication and professional advancement. Rather, it is a contribution to understanding humanity, society, and history, and to developing awareness of the issues that shape our contemporary world.

From this perspective, the journal continues its work guided by three complementary principles: academic rigour, intellectual openness, and service to researchers and knowledge production.

Our ambition is for Ijtihad to serve as a bridge for dialogue between Islam and the West, between tradition and modernity, and between different intellectual and research traditions. We seek to contribute, from our independent academic position, to the development of knowledge characterised by depth, balance, and integrity, and worthy of participation in international scholarly debate.

Dr Tijani Boulaouali
Editor-in-Chief

Ijtihad Journal for Islamic and Arabic Studies